Carmans River

Type
Freestone river, New York (East)
Designation
Fly-fishing only · Special-regulation trout water
USGS gauges
1 live
Guides
1 nearby
Shops
4 nearby

Today on the Carmans River

Reading the gauge…

Regulations & access Guides & shops

The Carmans River is a freestone river in New York, listed as Fly-fishing only by New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC), Bureau of Fisheries.

More about the Carmans River

1 USGS gauge on the water reports flow. 1 guide and 4 shops nearby are listed here; the nearest destination hub is Long Island: the Connetquot & the Carmans.

Updated · Sources: DEC Region 1 (Long Island) fly-fishing-only trout stream reaches, USGS Water Data

Representative photograph of similar water; not a photograph of this place.
Representative photograph, not this water.
Where it is

Carmans River is a freestone river in New York. Our destination hub Long Island: the Connetquot & the Carmans is 13 mi away in a straight line and lists it among its waters.

Flow now at the gauge
Reading the gauges…

Follow Carmans River for flow alerts

Pick one of its USGS gauges and hear from us when the flow moves into or out of its usual range for the date, or crosses a flow you set. We check the public USGS reading every 2 hours and email only when it crosses, at most once every 6 hours. Flow alone is not a fishing forecast or a safety call.

Follow this water

Signed in: one step. Otherwise we email a confirmation link first. Every alert has one-click links to stop it.

Where to fish

About this

Start from the agency's public access map. Nothing on this page grants or implies access: check the agency map, posted signs and landowner permission before you fish.

Nothing on this page grants or implies access.

Carmans River on the map

About this

Gauges, shops and guides within 40 miles

Map of Carmans River: gauges, shops and guides

RestroomsAccess map

Map of Carmans River with 1 USGS gauge, and shops and guides with an exact address within 40 miles.

Restrooms near Carmans River

Restrooms near Carmans River

Restrooms within 2 miles of Carmans River in a straight line, nearest first, with what anglers found when they went. The map says a restroom is there, not whether it is clean or open today.

No restroom mapped within 2 mi yet — add one you know.

Campgrounds, fishing access sites and boat ramps often have one that isn't on the map yet.

Restroom locations and map details: © OpenStreetMap contributors, Open Database License, read Oct 24, 2026. Ratings, answers and photos are members' own; who shared them is never shown, and every photo is reviewed before it appears. Visits older than 18 months no longer count. Distances are straight-line miles, not driving. Nothing here grants access to private land. Community guidelines.

More water near Carmans River

  • The Neversink River flowing between summer woods, seen from a bridge at Oakland ValleySpecial-regulation trout waterRepresentative photo · not Mud Creek
    Photo credit

    The Neversink River at Oakland Valley, New York. Photo: Daniel Case, CC BY-SA 4.0, cropped, via Wikimedia Commons Not Mud Creek.

    Mud Creek

    New York · about 6 mi

  • Esopus Creek running over a stony bed into a wooded Catskill hollow at Big IndianSpecial-regulation trout waterRepresentative photo · not Swan River
    Photo credit

    Esopus Creek at Big Indian, New York. Photo: Daniel Case, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons Not Swan River.

    Swan River

    New York · about 6 mi

  • Willowemoc Creek in early spring, bare trees reflected in a smooth poolSpecial-regulation trout waterRepresentative photo · not Patchogue River
    Photo credit

    Willowemoc Creek east of Livingston Manor, New York. Photo: Donald B. Siano, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons Not Patchogue River.

    Patchogue River

    New York · about 8 mi

  • The Beaverkill in early autumn, rain dimpling a broad pool below wooded hillsSpecial-regulation trout waterRepresentative photo · not Tuthills Creek
    Photo credit

    The Beaverkill in autumn rain. Photo: Jack Enright, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons Not Tuthills Creek.

    Tuthills Creek

    New York · about 8 mi

  • The East Branch Delaware River at its confluence with the Beaverkill, below wooded hillsSpecial-regulation trout waterRepresentative photo · not Beaverdam Creek
    Photo credit

    The East Branch Delaware River at its confluence with the Beaverkill, East Branch, New York. Photo: Daniel Case, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons Not Beaverdam Creek.

    Beaverdam Creek

    New York · about 13 mi

  • Morning fog over the Upper Delaware River, with a small boat on the waterSpecial-regulation trout waterRepresentative photo · not Connetquot River
    Photo credit

    A foggy morning on the Upper Delaware Scenic and Recreational River. Photo: National Park Service, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons Not Connetquot River.

    Connetquot River

    New York · about 14 mi

Regulations

About this

Seasons, limits, special regulations and closures for each reach are on the agency pages below. Read them before you go.

2 official designations

Each comes from the agency's own published list; where the list names a reach it is quoted. A designation applies to the listed reach, not necessarily the whole water. Listed in the finder under trout.

The water on the map

About this

Measured from the NHDPlus High Resolution (flowlines and waterbodies) (U.S. Geological Survey, read 2026-11-04) for this water’s own mapped feature. Rounded figures; they describe the channel, not today’s conditions.

Length
13.4 mi
Drains
87.6 sq mi
Watershed
Southern Long Island

Public land along it

About this

Areas the Protected Areas Database of the United States (PAD-US), public access (U.S. Geological Survey, Gap Analysis Project, read 2026-11-05) lists as owned or held in easement and open to the public, crossed by the mapped channel. Boundaries are mapped, not surveyed. Nothing on this page grants or implies access: check the agency map, posted signs and landowner permission before you fish.

4.5 of 12.9 mi on public land

  • Wertheim National Wildlife RefugeU.S. Fish and Wildlife Service · 3.9 mi · restricted
  • SUFFOLK COUNTYDEPT OF RL EST -CAMP PARK LandCounty Land · 0.6 mi

Nothing on this page grants or implies access.

Stocking records

About this

From the agency’s own records (Fish Stocking Lists (Actual): Beginning 2011, New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC), via data.ny.gov, read 2026-11-04), listed as Carmans River (Suffolk County). Check the agency for this season.

Past stockings, not a schedule

  • 2025: Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout in Mar, Apr, May, Oct (12 stockings, 2,450 fish).

  • 2024: Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout in Mar, Apr, May, Sep (12 stockings, 2,390 fish).

  • 2023: Brown Trout, Rainbow Trout in Mar, Apr, Sep (12 stockings, 2,380 fish).

Agency records

Guides and shops near Carmans River

About this

Listings marked Unclaimed are built from open map records and the business's own website: confirm licensing, rates, dates and hours directly.

Guides

4 shops nearby

How these are chosen

Guides whose own website names this water come first, nearest first. After them, fly-focused guides within 40 miles whose website does not name it. Distances are straight-line.

Shops: fly shops first. A distance is shown when the shop’s website gives its location (within 60 miles); otherwise the shop is in one of the towns within 25 miles of the water.

Guide and shop listings come from the Legendary directories.

Species and hatches

About this

What 1 nearby guide website mention: what guides advertise, not a survey or a promise of what you will catch.

Named on 1 nearby guide website

  • Striped bass1
  • Tuna1

When the bugs come off

Regional hatch months: Catskills and the Northeast
About this chart

8 hatches charted for the region, not measured on this water. From Pennsylvania Fish & Boat Commission.

  1. January: no charted hatch
  2. February: no charted hatch
  3. March: no charted hatch
  4. April: 3 charted hatches
  5. May: 2 charted hatches
  6. June: 1 charted hatch
  7. July: 1 charted hatch
  8. August: 1 charted hatch
  9. September: 2 charted hatches
  10. October: 1 charted hatch
  11. November: no charted hatch
  12. December: no charted hatch

Blue Quill (April) · Hendrickson (April) · Quill Gordon (April) · Green drake (May) · Mayflies (best hatches) (May) · Mayflies, stoneflies and caddisflies (June to September) · and 2 more on the chart

How we put this together

Named by guides nearby (within 40 miles), counted from the species each guide lists on its own site. No agency page we hold lists species for this water.

Long Island: the Connetquot & the Carmans

About this

Oakdale sits on Long Island's South Shore beside Connetquot River State Park Preserve, where the Connetquot runs to the Great South Bay; the Carmans, Swan and Patchogue rivers reach the bays to the east, and the Nissequogue flows north to Long Island Sound through Caleb Smith State Park Preserve near Smithtown.

Destination hub · 13 mi away in a straight line

Gear checklist

About this

A practical checklist for fly fishing small mountain trout streams: a short 3–4 weight rod, light line, a few buoyant dries and simple wet-wading gear, with estimated prices and where to buy.

An angler stands on a boulder at the edge of a fast forest stream and fishes the run

Small mountain streams

7′6″–8′6″ rod, 3–4 weight, floating line · Brook, cutthroat, rainbow and brown trout

Open the checklist
Videos for this water (5)

Watch: reading a trout stream

About this

Seams, shelves and soft water, shown on real rivers.

Public YouTube videos from established channels, chosen by us to support this page. Not sponsored; the creators are not affiliated with Legendary Fly Gear.

  • How I Learned to Read Water (Fly Fishing)Embedded from YouTube · Mad River Outfitters · not affiliated with Legendary Fly Gear. Watch on YouTube
  • How To Read The Water with Tom RosenbauerEmbedded from YouTube · The New Fly Fisher · not affiliated with Legendary Fly Gear. Watch on YouTube
  • Reading the Water to Successfully Locate TroutEmbedded from YouTube · Orvis Guide to Fly Fishing · not affiliated with Legendary Fly Gear. Watch on YouTube

Not sponsored All videos on reading water

Watch: nymphing basics

About this

Indicator rigs, depth and detecting the take.

Public YouTube videos from established channels, chosen by us to support this page. Not sponsored; the creators are not affiliated with Legendary Fly Gear.

  • 90° Nymph RigEmbedded from YouTube · Huge Fly Fisherman · not affiliated with Legendary Fly Gear. Watch on YouTube
  • Casting with an Indicator & Better Nymphing TechniquesEmbedded from YouTube · The New Fly Fisher · not affiliated with Legendary Fly Gear. Watch on YouTube

Not sponsored All videos on nymphing

Fish Tales

About this

Trip stories anglers chose to share publicly and tagged with Carmans River.

No stories from here yet.

Sources for this page

Not a statement of access, fish presence or conditions.

Something wrong?

All 13 sources and dates

A water page organises discovery. It does not assert public access, legal access, current fish presence, guide availability or fishing conditions.

Flows, gauge statistics and flood stages come from USGS and the National Weather Service when the page is shown. Regulations, stocking, species and season statements link to the agency that publishes them; this page copies only the species names and the quoted sentences. Guide and shop listings come from the Legendary directories. Position: the USGS gauge CARMANS RIVER AT YAPHANK NY. Water type is our own classification.